Value scale in drawing: what it is and how to make one

Updated:

A value scale is a row of tones that runs from white to black in even steps. You use it as a ruler for light and dark: make one with your own pencil, then compare every part of your drawing to it.

What does value mean in drawing?

Value is how light or dark an area is, regardless of colour. In a pencil drawing, value is the only thing you have, which is why it matters so much. It tells the viewer where the light is, how round a form is, and what sits in front of or behind something else.

Beginners often judge tone poorly because the eye adapts. A dark patch next to a darker one looks pale, and the same patch next to white looks heavy. A scale gives you something fixed to compare against.

How do I make a value scale with pencil?

The nine-step method described on the Making A Mark art blog follows the approach of the painter Denman Ross:

  1. Place white and black at either end.
  2. Make a medium grey that looks halfway between white and black.
  3. Make a light grey halfway between the medium grey and white.
  4. Make a dark grey halfway between the medium grey and black. That gives you five steps.
  5. Fill in four more greys, each midway between its neighbours, for nine steps.

The intervals should look equal. The same article suggests making your scale with the paper and media you normally use, which shows you how much effort the darkest values take.

For pencil work, draw a row of squares about 2 cm wide. Leave the first square as blank paper. Fill the last with the darkest tone you can reach by pressing firmly and layering. Fill the middle square and then work toward each end. Squint at the row from a distance: if two neighbours look the same, darken one of them.

You can print ready-made rows with our value scale worksheet.

How many steps do I really need?

Fewer than you might think. The Making A Mark article suggests that values can guide a composition and that trying only three or five can be enough.

  • Three values (light, middle, dark): the simplest way to plan a drawing. Great for judging a reference quickly.
  • Five values: enough for most beginner studies, including a sphere with a highlight, light tone, midtone, core shadow and reflected light.
  • Nine values: the classic range. Useful when you want very smooth gradients, such as a polished egg or a portrait.

Our value study tool takes a photo and reduces it to a handful of tones, so you can see the value pattern of your subject before you draw.

How do I use a scale to improve my drawings?

  1. Compare, do not guess. Hold your scale next to the drawing and squint. Find the step that matches an area, then fix it if needed.
  2. Check your darkest dark. If it matches only step 7 on a 9-step scale, you have room to push contrast.
  3. Limit your values. Decide before you start which three or five you will use. A drawing with fewer, well-placed values often looks stronger than one with many muddy ones.
  4. Convert your reference. Make a quick grayscale copy of the photo. If a bright red and a dark blue look the same grey, they share a value.
  5. Place values in the right order. Highlights, midtones and shadows should shift in a believable order across a form. The apple lesson is a good test of this.

Which exercises train my eye for value?

Start with a gradient strip: one long rectangle that darkens smoothly from white to black. Then try a mini study: draw a simple object in only three values, such as a mug or an apple. Later, move to the ice cream cone lesson, where you push the contrast across a wider range of tones.

You can combine this with hatching: LibreTexts notes that denser lines read as darker, so spacing alone can produce different steps. Our guide to hatching and cross-hatching shows how, and the shading worksheets give you grids to practise.

What mistakes should I avoid?

  • Making the middle steps too dark. Most people start too heavy and have no room for the darks. Begin light.
  • Uneven steps. If two steps are close and the next jumps, the scale will mislead you.
  • Skipping the white. Leave the paper untouched for your highlight.
  • Using the scale only once. Make a fresh one when you change paper or pencil.

Where does this fit in the bigger picture?

Value is the backbone of shading. After you are comfortable, look at shading techniques, how to shade with pencil and cast shadows explained. The whole group is collected in the shading and light topic hub.

How often should I use a value scale?

Make one whenever you change paper or pencil, and keep it beside your drawing for the first few weeks. Over time you will need it less, because your eye learns what a middle grey looks like. Even then, a quick five-step strip in the corner of the page is a cheap check before you finish. Treat it as a measuring tool rather than a rule, and adjust it to the lighting and the subject you are drawing.

If you want a lesson that talks you through tone on real paper, Guidart (free on iPhone and iPad) has voice-guided drawings and journey lessons on light and shadow. Afterwards you can photograph your drawing for an AI score and tips on shading. The AI score compares your photo with the original; it is not real-time and not a human teacher. Every free drawing and one premium drawing a day are free; Premium has a 7-day free trial and auto-renews (cancel in iOS Settings).

Sources

  1. Making A Mark, Denman Ross value scale (nine steps, equal intervals, uses)
  2. LibreTexts, Drawing Basics: Techniques in Mark Making

Frequently asked questions

What is a value scale?

A value scale is a row of tones arranged from the lightest (white) to the darkest (black) with even steps between them. Artists use it to judge how light or dark an area of a drawing really is.

How many steps should a value scale have?

Use as many as you can control. Three steps (light, middle, dark) is a good start, five is the most common for practice, and nine steps is the classic range that painter Denman Ross described.

Is value the same as colour?

No. Value is only how light or dark something is. A red and a blue can have the same value, which you can check by looking at a black-and-white copy of your reference.

Why do my drawings look flat even when I shade?

Often the values sit too close together. If your darkest tone is only mid-grey, the drawing cannot show a strong light. Making a scale shows you how dark your pencil can really go.

Related pages

GuidartLearn to draw on paper, free on iPhone and iPad
Download